Bushwick · New York City

Vinyl Fantasy

Bushwick records and comics in one shop, with heavier music, tapes, books and art giving the browse several distinct directions.

Vinyl Fantasy storefront at 194 Knickerbocker Ave in New York City.
Source

Why it is worth visiting

Vinyl Fantasy combines records with comics, books and art at its Knickerbocker Avenue shop. Metal and heavier music are visible in the record selection, while cassettes provide another route into small-label releases. The shop also handles used vinyl and sells selected records through its Record Harvest Discogs operation, so the physical and online sides are not identical. Its buying instructions are unusually useful for sellers: condition applies to both the record and its sleeve, with a stated preference for Very Good Plus or better material. For a buyer, the appeal is the combination of recorded music and printed work rather than a record shop with a few incidental gifts. Keep time for both if those interests overlap in your collection.

What you will find

New and used vinyl, cassettes, comics, books and art. Metal and punk are useful musical starting points, with selected used records also sold through Record Harvest online.

Genre strengths: Metal, Punk

Buying and selling

Vinyl Fantasy buys suitable vinyl collections, generally seeking Very Good Plus or better records and sleeves. Email a list and details through the official collection-selling instructions before bringing a larger batch.

Read the shop's buying instructions

Getting there

194 Knickerbocker Avenue in Bushwick. Use the Knickerbocker storefront address for the shop rather than the name of its separate online used-record operation.

Local tips

Treat the comics and books as part of the visit if they interest you. For a specific used pressing, check whether the Record Harvest listing is available at the storefront.

Keep the music going

More music. More stories. A longer tour.

About this guide

CouchLot researches store information using official sources, local reporting and collector communities. This is an independent guide to a third-party shop. Inventory and policies change. Check the shop's official source before making a special trip.

Last verified 2026-09-08.

Sources for this store

← All record stores in New York City